Loading

Stanford's Lucy

by julienM, published

Stanford's Lucy by julienM Jan 13, 2013

Featured Thing!

Description

This was an exercise in large model simplification. The original has 28 mio. triangles, this simplified version has been reduced to 460 000. Filesize went from 1.4 GB to 21 MB.

Recent Comments

view all
The 166mm Lucy statue was printed by my self-built DLP printer called WIZARD1. Its construction is similar to the B9C.
The print consists of 1581 layers à 105µm. For more infos please look here (May 30th):
http://forum.david-3d.com/viewtopic.php?f=17&t=4306&start=195
We imported the Lucy model into AVAYALIVE MMO Virtual Museum Visit at wa692.avayalive.com Here is a screenshot of the 2m. high statue. twitter.com/joerigby1339/status/465286291160965122/photo/1pic.twitter.com/Hp38GWyTEr
this thing is beautiful! thanks for sharing

More from Sculptures

view more

Liked By

view all

License

Give a Shout Out

If you print this Thing and display it in public proudly give attribution by printing and displaying this tag. Print Thing Tag

Instructions

Recommended file: Lucy_3M_O10_20%.stl

Update2: A print of the head at 50% scale, printed at a layer height of 0.3, looks very nice. At this scale, the statue would be 70 cm high. I'm now very motivated to build a Rostock derivative, although that would normally only allow 40 cm height.

Update: The mesh was sampled with 3M points, then an out of core Poisson reconstruction applied, followed by quadric edge collapse decimation (to 20%, hence the filename). The result is a 22 MB Mesh much better than the Lucy_simplified, at no extra size. I really need to document this all logically, this might not be the best place for it.

Taken from the Stanford 3D scanning site (http://graphics.stanford.edu/data/3Dscanrep/). The Stanford CGL asks that this model not be transfomed, morphed etc.

The original file was not manifold, making a straightforward simplification in MeshLab (see thingiverse.com/thing:40632) difficult. As a workaround, the statue was subsampled to 500K points in CloudCompare (http://www.danielgm.net/cc/). A reconstrucion of the resulting point-cloud should be possible with the poisson-reconstruction function in CloudCompare. As I am more familiar in Meshlab, I used that instead.

The workflow for a point-cloud to volume conversion is as follows:
Filters > Point Set > Estimate radius from density
Filters > Point Set > Compute normals for point sets
Filters > Remeshing, etc > Surface Reconstruction: Poisson (I used Octree Depth: 9)
Netfabb repair, due to some small errors

Update: I've uploaded the script for a surface reconstruction in MeshLab (.mlx):
Filters > Show current filter script
Open script > "Surface reconstruction.mlx"


The parameters for all stages in the script can be changed beforehand, then everything can be executed at once. MeshLab also installs a server, so the script can be executed from the command line. This however is more useful when working on a lot of models at once.

Slicing at 25% scale (200 mm wide at 45°, 400 mm high) for a maximum Rostock build goes to 6 GB in RAM on my machine, so it is probably impractical to use a model with less simplification. The original model, converted to .stl, can surpass 14 GB in RAM when manipulated in Meshlab, so the point-cloud has also been included (.asc), for those wanting to try out this method. The original Model can be downloaded from the Stanford CGL site.
The 166mm Lucy statue was printed by my self-built DLP printer called WIZARD1. Its construction is similar to the B9C.
The print consists of 1581 layers à 105µm. For more infos please look here (May 30th):
http://forum.david-3d.com/viewtopic.php?f=17&t=4306&start=195
We imported the Lucy model into AVAYALIVE MMO Virtual Museum Visit at wa692.avayalive.com Here is a screenshot of the 2m. high statue. twitter.com/joerigby1339/status/465286291160965122/photo/1pic.twitter.com/Hp38GWyTEr
this thing is beautiful! thanks for sharing
Thanks for reducing it to 23m. I am going to try to print this on my prusa. I can only make some that is 120mm tall. opened it with repG then I scaled it down so it would fit. When I save the stl back out it grew to 123M. WTF? Could you reduce it again? There seem to be to many points for the small model I would like to print.
I don't think my printer could catch all that detail any way. Thanks for model at any rate. I have a friend who is prepairing for her PHD at stanford and I thought this would be a nice thing to make for her.
I've made a Version that is now 112 mm tall. It's also simplified and only has 25K Faces.
How large is the original when in printable STL format? And is there any way i could get it? I'm really interested in using this model as a detail showcase. Is it slice-ready or is there work to be done? (I've never actually worked on a model before, unfortunately i'm a complete noob when it comes to cleaning up 3d forms, etc) but i do have a capable machine with 16gb of RAM. If there is any way i can get this to a printable state i would be overjoyed!
Going with the full mesh proved difficult. Even a 5 million point subsample crashed MeshLab. This doesn't matter howerver. With a Poisson reconstruction with a depth of 11 (just in case you ever want to try) I obtained a super high resolution mesh. At 500 MB this is a bit heavy though. At depth 10, the mesh still looked very good.

I applied a quadric edge collapse decimation to 20%. That is the 2nd last image you see. The last image is a comparison of the first "_simplified" to the "sampled 3 million points, Poisson with Octree depth 10, redused to 20%". Same filesize, better result.
I've not made a printable .stl at full resolution yet. When deleting non-manifold edges and vertices, as well as deleting self-intersecting faces, there are 12.000 holes in the model. It's impractical to make MeshLab close them, as they have to be selected manually, unless I missed an option somewhere. I'm rebuilding the model from the full point-cloud as well as a 5 million subsample (5x higher). I'll upload if I succeed.

The main problem I see is Slic3r though. It burns through memory. The highly simplified model needs 6 GB. The model is 1.4 m high. Maybe if I scale before loading to Slic3r, it'l get better. Can you let me know, what build envelop you are going for? I'll then scale and upload that as well.
Sorry for the late response, and thanks for yours! I'm running a Replicator 2 so the build area is max like 6x10x6h i think, i would like a 4-5in tall model ideally. To be honest i only caught half of the terminology you just threw but I can appreciate the amount of work this must be, especially with all of the intersections and holes, thanks again for continuing to work on it!
Just download Lucy_3M_O10_20.stl and scale to 8%. I noticed that it makes no difference if the model is scaled before going into the slicing software.

At that size the slicing should be pretty straightforward.

I'd be interested to see the printed part. Won't be possible without support and some features might be lost at that size. I really like this statue now. You can see the head I printed.That was at 50%:

The technical stuff is for me, so I remember, as well as others who might want to try something like this. I will have to find a more structured way to document this stuff.
Top