Tunable Tolerance Tetrahedron Twist Timewasting Toy
by profhankd, published
Liked ByView All
Give a Shout Out
If you print this Thing and display it in public proudly give attribution by printing and displaying this tag.Print Thing Tag
This tunable tolerance tetrahedron twist timewasting toy thing was inspired by http://www.thingiverse.com/thing:186372 . The problem with that thing was that it was just an STL file, with no means for adjusting the "fit" tolerance or scaling. So, one of the students in my lab, Zachary Snyder, spent valuable should-have-been-studying-for-final-exams time on deriving his own formula for it in OpenSCAD... and then I spent too much time trying to print it with various parameters and tweaking the design. Oh yeah, it also can take a shockingly long time to solve the puzzle... especially shocking given that it's just two pieces!
The 20160630 version has a few minor, but significant improvements. The original version uses a turn of 1.0, which makes the parts not fit with those from the new design unless tenth_turns is set to 10 rather than the new default value of 12.
Can print assembled (intertwined) without supports or as separate parts with/without supports; good to use a brim if printing parts separately. Tests ranging in size from 20 to 75mm on a side were printed on two MakerGear M2 (at up to 150mm/s) and a Wanhao I3 (at up to 60mm/s) using PLA with extrusion heights of 0.1mm to 0.25mm. The parts vary dramatically in thickness, so be warned that thin sections are much more fragile than the thicker sections, and extra shells or infill may be needed to improve durability when idiots try to solve the puzzle by forcing pieces together....
The 20160630 version defaults to having slightly thicker thin sections, which help strength. Higher dimensional accuracy prints have been made printing the two parts separately using Slic3r-produced 10% 3D hexagonal fill and supports with 2 layers of shell. You can print two copies of tttttt20160630noUK1.stl to have no UK logo or one copy each of tttttt20160630u.stl and tttttt20160630k.stl for the version with the UK logo.
Believe it or not, this thing can actually print assembled without supports! The 75mm/side pink and blue ones were printed on two different MakerGear M2, blue with 1mm gap and pink with 0.75mm gap, then taken apart and reassembled intermixed. Although both were successful as print assembled without supports, both did require some careful prying with a knife edge to break the minor welds caused by sag during printing. Using very thin walls, 2mm or less, actually helps when printing intertwined.
Alternatively, you can get a nicer print by using a slicer to separate the two pieces and then print them with support to the bed and a brim to keep them stable. The second STL file was created using Cura for precisely that transformation (Cura's "Lay Flat" command is also helpful if you want to rotate one of the tetrahedrons, as I did), and pieces printed from that file on a MakerGear M2 (at 0.25mm) and Wanhao I3 (at 0.1mm) fit together effortlessly -- that's how the blue (M2, 0.25mm) and natural (I3, 0.1mm) examples in the photo were made.
Printing the 20160630 one-part-at-a-time STLs produces remarkably clean and accurate prints. In fact, the only cleaning needed is snapping-off the support. I didn't even use a file!
Customizer Parameters Are In Microns
The Customizer still doesn't understand decimal input, so all the parameters to this design are given in integer microns -- 1/1000 mm units. For example, a good value for the gap is between about 0.25mm and 1mm, which would be obtained by setting Micron Gap between 250 and 1000 in the Customizer.
Solving The Puzzle
If you print this as separate parts, you will undoubtedly be tempted at some point to just force the pieces together. DO NOT FORCE THEM. With a 1mm gap, the pieces are actually a DISTURBINGLY LOOSE FIT -- if you are putting them together the right way. Thing 186372 didn't leave a gap, so they talk about needing to sand the parts, but no sanding is required if you leave a gap (although you'll still want to file-off any remaining brim, support material, or hanging threads/stray blobs).
What is the right way to put the two pieces together? Well, the version with the UK logo makes it a little easier to visualize, but the truth is that the simple spiral slicing doesn't line-up with the tetrahedron in one of the planes you expect it to. Once you find the right plane, it is a trivial matter of literally screwing the two parts together.
Upgrade this Thing with Thingiverse AppsCustomization
Edit, personalize, or revise this ThingPrint Fulfilment
Order a print of this ThingTools and Utilities
Repair, slice, or enhance this Thing
Tunable Tolerance Tetrahedron Twist Timewasting Toy by profhankd is licensed under the Creative Commons - Attribution license.
What does this mean?
- You must attribute (give credit) to the creator of this Thing.
- Remixing or Changing this Thing is allowed.
- Commercial use is allowed.
Show Some Love
Say thanks by giving profhankd a tip and help them continue to share amazing Things with the Thingiverse community.Tip Designer
We're sure profhankd would love to see what you've printed. Please document your print and share a Make with the community.
To post a Make simply visit this Thing again and click I Made One to start uploading your photo. It’s even easier to post a Make via the Thingiverse Mobile app (available via Google Play and Apple App Store).