Loading
Hey! This thing is still a Work in Progress. Files, instructions, and other stuff might change!
Prot0typ1cal

Hlidskjalf (Odin's Chair)

by Prot0typ1cal Sep 26, 2016
Download All Files

Thing Apps Enabled

Please Login to Comment

Still a WIP.
However, scroll through the images, there's more info there if you're serious

The image with the size of the parts cropped.
I read the reprap forum and your calculations are very encouraging. Therefore, I want to repeat the design.

I would encourage you to design your own, using rods instead of linear guides.

If I were to do it over, would probably had opted for a single coreXY with a tool changer.

In the process of completely revamping the top motor and pulley configuration with more printed parts, to provide more support for the pulleys.

The initial design ripped itself to pieces as the loads were too high.

If I take HyperCube as a basis. Can be install Dual X Carrige on it?

And what's wrong with linear guides?

Suggest you take a look at Lars coreXYU project: https://reprap.org/forum/read.php?397,775415

Linear guides require a high level of precision for alignment, otherwise they will bind.

Exists a BOM for this printer or detail plans?

Amazing design, can't wait to see it printing! I am thinking about to start to build one.

Just saw this now can't believe I missed it. WoW, I'm in the middle of building a core xy following great advice from Mark Rehorst's Blog. This build is for making guitar bodies in one shot. Fingers crossed. Your dual x heads are very nicely done. I have a grand Idea to build full size Kayaks and canoes, and this solves the problem of building both sides at the same time, boats like to be built evenly. Bow and Stern points might be a little challenging. We'll see. The budget is going to be horrendous might start next year. Oops talking to much, again your machine is absolutely beautiful. Please keep us posted.

I wonder if CoreXY IDEX is capable to running both carriages (/sync) at the same time (e.g. duplication mode, ..)? I'm searching for a variant that is capable of doing that where you are not constrained to put 2 motors on the x-gantry.

Yes, it could run duplication mode. My rig has a Z offset between the two heads, so I can't ATM.
You would need to add adjustment in the extruder mounts so they both will share a common Z zero (same plane).
Of course, that goes without saying, just saying :)

uhh. that's interesting. I made a Tevo IDEX, so i know the difficulties with Z. But i hadn't nearly as much components to align (as with your tornado)

I'm remaking everything in Aluminum, so am considering adding adjustment slots to the X carriages to facilitate alignment, when I get to those. That way don't have to mess with the Toranados, as eventually they'll also get replaced with all metal extruders.

do you have any prints to show the detail capabilities of this beautiful machine!?

How can the MGN rails be fixed to the 4020 extrusions?
Is it a pain to align them?
Nice job!

I used M3 T-nuts, solid not the drop ins. And used ALL the holes in the rail.
Yes, it was a PITA. Had to suspend the extrusion on 123 blocks on a granite surface plate, and indicate repeatidly to keep them within a .0005" of each other on the gantry while tightening every SHCS. The Y and Z rails were easier as the rails only needed to be parallel to the face of the 2060.

Thanks, next time I wont buy MGN chinese knock offs, buy rails with 2 trucks (blocks) if you need two. NEVER try to add them like I did. Had to repack the bearings and throw away a half dozen blocks that were FUBAR.

Did I miss a post or the details on the firmware?

Great work btw! It's awesome to have this build!

CoreXYU Firmware has been incorporated into RepRapFirmWare for either Duet or RADDS (your choice)

https://github.com/dc42/RepRapFirmware

Now have power, 1000 Watts of 24VDC.
Will be replacing the 2x stepper driver extension with a 3x that includes 2x more fan outputs, so will wire up extruders when that arrives.
Plus will get the ATP-5 1/4" tooling plate soon for the bed, so will be able to wire up the heatbed at that time as well.
PanelDue working, in process of hacking firmware to support CoreXYU.

Are you using standard CAT-5 cable to wire your motors, etc.? Is that a large enough gauge wire to supply the correct loads for hot ends, etc.?

Actually. it's CAT3. It's 24 AWG and the cables don't move. Also used same for the stationary end stops for Y and Z.
At 24VDC (1.4A stepper) is only a 1.5% voltage drop over 1.5 meter cable length, that's half of the max recommended of 3%.
http://www.calculator.net/voltage-drop-calculator.html

For the hot ends have ultra-flexible multi-strand 15 wire 22 AWG cable going to the carriages and will use 4 wires, 2 each for the negative and positive leads for the cartridge heaters. Plus 2 for the thermistor, 2 for the heat sink fan, 3 for the filament cooling fan, and 4 for the NEMA 14 direct drive (total 15). The smaller cables that go to the carriages now are for the X endstops only, and is only 26 AWG.

Amazing. I will follow up your progress!

This is absolutely beautiful. I'm designing my own CoreXY and came across yours when researching stacked belts vs crossed belts to see if the torque form stacked belts really matters. Does your independent system work reliably? My design is very similar to yours using 4 linear guide rails for the z axis, and 2 for the y, but I hadn't considered doing independent heads for dual extrusion. The design of this machine is phenomenal. The only change I think I would make for mine would be to use E3D's Aero heads for each extruder/hotend.

Hey buddy, i plan to replace my crappy Prusia I3 rework by your awesome build!
Does the current version usable or not?

I loved your project.. it is the innovation community seeks (at least I seek) =) waiting for your machine to print! I want to build this, but so complicated to understand with pictures. Can you post 3D cad files for us to examine the completed machine?

As soon as it's done I'll be posting the final assembly. Still a "work in progress".

Hello,

Really like this project. Go big or go home!

I've got a large build underway as well but single extruder based on one of Jetguy's "Big-Boy" printers. Mine is a four lead-screw Z-lift with a 14"x14"x36" build volume: "Tall-Boy". Z-travel is a work in progress; its hard to keep things really square over this much travel.

Question: where did you source the high quality GT2 belt? All I've found is the fiberglass core Chinese stuff.

Thank you much,

Mark Napier

The more I look at this design the more I like it. I think the only change I can see making is proably the XY axis looks heavier than it needs to be unless you plan to do some light milling as well.

Thanks,
Absolutely, some light milling as well. Plan is linking the two X-carriages with a single spindle mount plate.
Beauty is, with dual coreXY, I'll have 4x motors driving the milling head.

As a 3d printer, the non printing head adds it's motors to moving the "heavy" Y-gantry in Y, while the other head prints in X and Y.
Acceleration calculations shows the CoreXYU arrangement to be more efficient than a standard CoreXY, especially on 45/135 degree moves.

I can't wait to see this working, I wish to build it already, only thing I would rather do instead of a pure corexy is a system like d-bot with no crossing belts?

Congratulations on this awesome work.

Well, amazing & interesting, fisrt for the big build size, second for the two x-axis independent Heads.
But: wich software ist capable to control that?

RepRap firmware can (has been) be expanded to support the dual X in a CoreXY, know known as CoreXYU.
Most slicers already support dual extruders, though Hlidskjalf will have modified Repeteir Host to provide desired control of both heads.

Waiting for all the wires and connectors... also waiting for the last of the fasteners, and the plywood top and sides.

pfft, I hate waiting :p

Based on what you have so far it will be worth it. Can't wait to see it in action and see the BOM.

impressive work
can you put a x_t file of the whole assembly please

Thanks,
Just adding as I go along ATM.
Plan on releasing a full model, with Bill of Material when complete.

What are you using to design? If the solidworks / fusion / etc. files could be shared that would be incredibly generous of you. Worst case step files, but native files are so nice when wanting to remix.

I like the look of this machine! Very nice.

I am really looking forward to see this printer working, or at least moving the first steps!!!!

A really great work.

Thanks :)
Added a new photo of the frame.
You'll see the right print head is belted (lower run). Hope to cut the plywood sides and top this weekend.
With just the one head, it will be compatible with the current Repitier firmware (Phase 1)
After the one head is proved out, can modify the software to run two heads (Phase 2).

Closer to phase 1 today.
Frame is bolted together and will begin wiring for a single head CoreXY.
Will add the plywood sides and top when weather allows.

Comments deleted.

Updated pics to show belt routing. Almost done 3d printing all the required pieces for assembly.
There's a few more parts that are pending:

  1. Spool holders. 2 will be on the back side under where the belts twist. Need filament guides as well, maybe sensors too.
  2. Machine Feet. Getting some isolation pads from McMaster-Carr and will design around those.
  3. Printer face. Includes mounting for the 7" display and electronics. Thinking a pull out drawer.

This assembly uses twenty (20) of these POM idlers:
https://www.aliexpress.com/item/3D-printer-accessories-10-pcs-dual-bearing-smooth-TIMING-BELT-adjustable-idler-wheel-delrin-POM-H/32392577798.html?spm=2114.13010608.0.0.drreTp

Turns out, illustrious Chinese comrades bored from both sides to leave a step in the center so the bearings don't push through. Good solution, yet creates a defect when you pass a bolt and tighten it, it locks up the bearings because they don't mate on the inner race.

Had to press out all the bearings, which breaks the center POM ring, good thing it's POM as it shears clean. Then reassemble with a washer/spacer. Sure the bearings may walk out (very slim), but at least they turn.

I have no words about the amount of work you are doing, but i'm watching closely your project, this is the best i have seen on this site!!!!

Every day I do a little more. Today I finished machined the toothed idlers, by boring the 5mm stock I.D. out to 11mm and then turning the nose off on a lathe to make perfect idlers from these that I got from eBay: http://www.ebay.com/itm/231825108382 and http://www.ebay.com/itm/291694937751

Only the motor mounts and drive pulley brackets left to design. Will be bolting it all together soon so I can start on the wiring. The software will be RepRap/Repetier with modifications to support the dual CoreXY drive.

That PSU is 600$

Yea, it's overkill. The whole printer is...

Nice job, I'm assuming is gonna cost you a fortune get all the pieces milled, a question, what's the purpose of milling the bore of the ball screw support? Is just because was tight?

Sorry if the pic is misleading. Actually just truing up the bolt surface (with the 6 holes), by milling a light cut. And that's the Z-Flange, AKA nut mount. The supports are named "Anchor" and "Floater", to indicate which end of the ball screw they reside.

Hi,
If you don't mind, i can suggest you that the last file posted can be printed upside down, with much better result and less plastic, as the support is not required then, and the piece can have a much better look, the angles are not critical upside down.(is just a comment, nothing important) :-)
Cheers

The "Anchor" (for the ball screw) had almost 2mm curling on the corners printed at 0.2 with the large side down (original version), even with raft. So flipped it and added supports (version 3), now it prints flat and parallel. Better to use a little more material and have a usable part. FWIW, I'm printing PLA and don't have a heated bed on my rep2.

Thanks for your comments :)

MAN!!!!!
If you manage to have this up and running i'll buy one from you, no matter how much it cost!!!!!!
This is the printer of the year :-))

Busy printing Z-FLANGEs (2), Z-CARRs (4) and TOP90s (8). Printing red pieces at 0.2 res/4 shells/50% infill, and grey bits 0.1 res/4 shells/50% infill. Running out of filament as most that I print is prototypes and get versioned into the obsolete bin. If a part stays in the Thing files for more than a few days means it's in the current build. Probably about 6 to 8 printed pieces left to design.

Need to mill some reliefs in the top 2020 cross bars, the retainer nut for the ball screw fixed support needs more room than allowed by the 20mm gap. Plenty of space for the 10mm to 5mm shaft coupling. Also one the machining list is boring the toothed idlers for bearings.

Realized the cheap MGN12 linear guides and extra H blocks from China are complete crap. Replaced bearings in one from McMaster-Carr and tweaked the wire retainer so it didn't bind the ball return. So far it's the only usable carriage, you get what you pay for...

When all will be done, do you think that we Can expected à BOM ?

Amazing job man!!
I am watching you.......

This is gonna be The Printer!!!!

Eventually... Next will print out a Y carriage to check dimensions, adjust because it never prints perfect. Then print two once it meets my specs.

Nice design, let's see what your pen is capable to do :-))

Thanks, we'll see if my Makerbot Rep2 can make parts that fit :p